Publishers Weekly
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved

Jones (An American Marriage) delivers a triumphant novel of two motherless girls from rural Honeysuckle, La., who follow very different paths into adulthood. Vernice “Niecy” Davis is orphaned as an infant and raised reluctantly by her free-spirited aunt Irene, who dispenses such advice as “If you ever get a chance in life, grab you a preacher, but just temporarily. Don’t fool around and end up being somebody’s first lady.” Before Niecy learns to talk, she befriends Annie Johnson, who’s being raised by her grandmother after her “trifling” mother, Hattie Lee, left her at one month old. In Annie and Niecy’s alternating narration, the women reflect on their abandonment—Niecy’s in a permanent sense, as her father killed her mother and himself, while Annie always hopes that someday Hattie Lee will return and grow to love her. After high school, Niecy leaves for Spelman College in Atlanta, where her wealthy roommate, Joette, nicknames her “country mouse” and chastises her for spending so much time thinking about her “other girlfriend,” Annie, who’s been writing to Niecy about her torrid misadventures on the way to Memphis in search of Hattie Lee with her ex-boyfriend’s cousin Bobo. Annie’s and Niecy’s paths continue to diverge, first when Niecy entertains a suitor at Spelman and later when Annie gets unexpectedly pregnant. Still, they remain the most important person to the other even as it feels like they’re on “different sides of a waterfall,” as Annie puts it in a letter. Throughout, Jones tells her protagonists’ stories with grace, humor, and pathos. It’s a tour de force. Agent: Jane Dystel, Dystel, Goderich & Bourret. (Feb.)

Library Journal
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

Jones (An American Marriage) crafts two unforgettable protagonists in this moving ode to friendship and self-discovery. Vernice "Niecy" and Annie, both motherless and fiercely devoted to each other since childhood, take diverging paths when they turn 18. Niecy leaves for Spelman College in Atlanta, while Annie travels to Memphis in search of the mother who abandoned her, seeking both a reunion and acceptance. Though distance separates them, their bond remains unshaken. As their journeys unfold, each young woman grapples with identity, belonging, and resilience. With evocative prose, Jones carries the women through moments of hardship and growth as they navigate the complexities of the Deep South in the 1950s and '60s, where race and gender profoundly shape their experiences. Narrators Hobbs and Pean deliver compelling performances, bringing depth and nuance to the characters. As they alternate between perspectives, they establish distinct voicing, pacing, and emotional texture, capturing the characters' inner lives and communicating the weight of their choices. VERDICT Already a favorite for book clubs, this audiobook elevates a powerful story with standout narration. Highly recommended for public library collections.—Christa Van Herreweghe

Book list
From Booklist, Copyright © American Library Association. Used with permission.

Jones, whose previous novel, An American Marriage (2018), was an Oprah's Book Club pick, is back with a tender love song to southern Black families, communities, and female friendships. Annie and Niecy have grown up as “cradle friends” in small-town Mississippi, “tended to but never mothered.” Niecy’s mother is dead and Annie’s has simply “up and left.” Their lives diverge dramatically after their last year of high school: Niecy graduates and reinvents herself at Spelman College, while Annie runs away with three friends, hoping to track down her errant mother in Memphis. Neither finds exactly what she was looking for, yet each girl will experience profound self discovery. Told in alternating first-person narration and in letters, Jones’ novel is an intimate portrayal of the anxieties and mixed messages of African American girlhood in the early 1960s that linger in adulthood. Pining for their mothers, both girls will seek replacements: Niecy’s a tippling Atlanta social climber, Annie’s the no-nonsense madam of a brothel. As each faces her personal demons and disappointments, their unbreakable childhood bond keeps them anchored in a friendship transcending blood relatives and romantic partners. Jones deftly conveys the nuances of Southern Black culture in this novel full of depth, pain, and beauty.

Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

The story of a lifelong friendship born in hardship and tempered by adversity. Growing up in Honeysuckle, Louisiana, in the 1950s, Vernice and Annie are best friends who share an unhappy bond: Both have lost their mothers. When Niecy was 6 months old, her father murdered hers. Annie’s abandoned her when she was still “womb-wet.” As girls, they’re inseparable, but their paths diverge in young adulthood. Cautious, sensible Niecy goes to Spelman College, where she finds a community of strong Black women, then marries into a wealthy family. Desperate to find her mother, Annie runs away from home and embarks on a journey that will take her to some of the less savory corners of the Jim Crow South. Even though they’re separated by distance and circumstance, their closeness endures—as does the trauma of mother loss. Niecy and Annie are both rich, captivating characters and the ways in which their lives complement each other is emotionally satisfying—for them as well as the reader. As Annie puts it, “Nobody would for one second think to call me shy if I stood next to Niecy—who has been a young lady since the day she was born. And with me around, nobody would ever call Niecy poor or homely. In that way, we kept each other from being the thing we most didn’t want to be.” This is Jones’ first new novel sinceAn American Marriage (2018), and it’s reminiscent of that critically acclaimed and bestselling work. As in her last book, the author interrogates social injustice through the lens of personal relationships while exploring the ways in which it shapes those relationships, and she does this in language that is intimate, conversational, and musical all at once. For instance, this is how Niecy recollects an encounter with a kind woman: “‘Oh Cher.’ The sympathy in her voice was thick and sticky like Pet Milk. I opened my lips like a baby bird, starving in a forsaken nest.” Beautifully written and powerfully compelling. Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.