Publishers Weekly
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved

The first novel from Diamond (Searching for John Hughes, a memoir) weaves a rich tapestry of a Chicago Jewish family through the stories of a gangster and his 30-something grandson. Elijah Mendes returns in disgrace from Silicon Valley after his former business partners were caught misappropriating company funds. Back in his hometown, where his mother, Eve, has terminal cancer, he learns that his late grandfather Yitz Kaplan owned a Jewish cemetery. A rabbi has been trying to contact Eve about the property, which she doesn’t want to talk about, fueling Elijah’s curiosity. A parallel narrative reveals how Yitz travelled from Odessa to Chicago in 1909 as a boy with his brother, Solomon, to escape attacks against Jews in Ukraine. Searching for information about his grandfather, Elijah discovers from newspaper archives that a 14-year-old Yitz was charged with the murder of a “known hoodlum.” Yitz was cleared of the crime, but the event marked the beginning of his rise in the city’s underworld—a “little Oliver Twist,” according to Eve. Diamond crafts an affecting portrait of the bond mother and son gradually form over revelations about the past, and the narrative is shot through with Elijah’s intriguing meditations on his origins and what they say about himself. The result is a memorable tale of the American dream gone sideways. Agent: Peter Steinberg, UTA. (Sept.)

Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Having flamed out at a California startup, Elijah Mendes returns home broke to be with his cancer-stricken mother in Chicago, where he uncovers dark secrets about his Jewish family. His mother, Eve, an acclaimed poet working on her memoir, has avoided learning about the criminal activities of her Russian-born father, Yitzhak “Yitz” Kaplan. But Elijah’s research reveals he was the murderous head of a Jewish Maxwell Street mob. In alternating chapters, the novel traces Yitz’s rise from errand boy for head mobster Avi Kaminsky to the equally ruthless killer who deposes him. Yitz’s more-reserved younger brother, Solomon, is happiest running his classy butcher shop, but his place in infamy was secured when as a boy he saved Yitz from an attacker by lethally shoving a wooden stick into the assailant’s neck. The women in the story, including Eve’s ill-fated mother, do not have a happy time of it. Elijah, whose late lawyer father “was a Hispanic Jew or Moroccan or something,” ultimately finds connections between his (Elijah’s) empty existence and that of his grandfather, whose corpse “continued the lonely existence that the man who once inhabited the body experienced every moment of his life.” First-time novelist Diamond does a solid job of tracing the rise and fall of the Jewish mob in Chicago, highlighting their dealings with the Irish (who didn’t learn “to respect the Jews”) and the Italians (enemies with “flair and style”). You can’t go wrong with characters named Izzy the Trout and Jerry Knish. It’s too bad Elijah is such a bland protagonist and that the novel contains so few surprises or revelations—though Elijah’s dis of Hyde Park may qualify as one for certain readers. An ambitious novel with a better backstory than contemporary one. Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.