Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

A felonious witch and a ingenious young boy match wits in this latest folktale from Wahl (Rosa's Parrot, p. 307, etc.). Johnny, too small yet to do chores with his father, assists his mother by bringing the buttermilk to town, earning the moniker ``Little Johnny Buttermilk.'' Danger looms in the guise of a villainous crone who covets Johnny's burden. Waylaid by the devious hag, Johnny refuses to relinquish his milk, causing the witch to decide that he will make a tasty addition to her meal. Concerned about a purchase she left in town (ironically, she's afraid someone will steal it), she leaves the sack containing Johnny and his milk by the side of the road and he promptly escapes. Due to a clever refilling of the sack, the witch doesn't discover Johnny's defection until she returns home. Relying on his ingenuity, Johnny continues to elude and eventually best the witch. Mazzucco's lively illustrations are an integral part of the story; her comical depiction of the action and sly incorporation of a cat and mouse into nearly every scene heap measures of fun into the witty retelling. (Picture book. 4-8)

Book list
From Booklist, Copyright © American Library Association. Used with permission.

Ages 3^-6. Little Johnny wants to help his mother by bringing the buttermilk to town and selling it. But on the way, the boy meets a witch, who insists on having the buttermilk for free. Johnny's refusal gets him tossed into a sack, but when the witch leaves, he escapes and puts brambles in instead. Twice more, Johnny tricks the witch and escapes from her bag, the last time causing her to burst with anger. Based on an English story, this follows traditional folktale conventions and is pleasing in its familiarity. The watercolor artwork, with its angular shapes, is richly colored but offers few surprises to children, though the climactic scene has lots of energy. Buy this one for the story rather than the art. --Ilene Cooper

School Library Journal
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

PreS-Gr 1-In this retelling of an English folktale, Little Johnny helps his mother by selling buttermilk. He comes up against a witch, outwits her three times, and lives happily ever after. Events in this picture book are similar to Eileen Colwell's "Jack Buttermilk," found in Round about and Long Ago (Houghton, 1974; o.p.). Although the beginnings and ends of these two variations differ, the basic premise of foiling the witch remains the same. In the earlier retelling, Jack and his mother are poor. Jack begs buttermilk from a nearby farmer then sells it for money. In this version, Johnny's father tells him he's too young to help feed the pigs, yet his mother tells him that he can help by selling buttermilk in town each day. How's that for a contradiction? After being outwitted three times, Colwell's witch leaves Jack alone, but Wahl's witch angrily bursts into pieces before all ends happily. Except for the occasional odd facial expression, Mazzucco's vibrant full-page and full-spread paintings match and/or extend the text. However, Colwell's story is more satisfying.-Kathleen Simonetta, Indian Trails Public Library District, Wheeling, IL (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

Horn Book
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

Collected by the author from an oral source in England, this tale has a predictable structure that makes it easy for children to retell. A witch keeps trying to steal Johnny's buttermilk, but he flees each time after playing a trick on her. The stylized paintings have some amusing details, but the tale ultimately loses tension as the witch invariably forgets something in town and leaves Johnny free to escape. Reviewed by: mg (c) Copyright 2010. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted. All rights reserved.