Horn Book
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

In this second series entry, mysterious librarian Amicus Arcane (The Fearsome Foursome) is back to share more paranormal tales. This time, a young man named William listens in return for a chance to see the medium, Madame Leota, who can help him speak to his deceased sister. The four loosely connected stories-within-the-story are ominous but not too scary, while eerie line drawings reinforce the pseudo-creepy vibe. (c) Copyright 2018. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Amicus Arcane, librarian of the haunted mansion from which this series issues, returns with more tales intended to terrify.For years "up-and-coming writer" William Gaines has been searching for an authentic medium to help him contact his dead sister to ask her forgiveness. Along the way he's debunked every medium he's met. When a mysterious stranger offers to introduce him to the fabled (and dead) Madame Leota, William jumps at the chancebut he must first, for some unspecified reason, suffer through four tales from the mansion library: a nonsensical revenge tale set in a roving carnival, a tale of vampiric inheritance and remorse, a slightly more-sensical revenge tale of zombie love, and, the creepiest of the lotthough still unsatisfyingthe story of an orphan's suffocation by cockroaches. William's portion ends with a connection to The Fearsome Foursome (2016), the first Haunted Mansion collection, but few spook seekers will make it to the close. This second in the series inspired by Disney's Haunted Mansion ride regularly contradicts itself and is marred by clumsy writing. Intrusive narrator Arcane's comments on his own comments are repetitive and never as amusing as their speaker believes them. Comic-book-artist Jones' eerie, scratchy occasional illustrations are wasted here. Ghost hunters best look elsewhere for their scares. (Horror. 9-12) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.