Library Journal
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

Heartbroken after a failed engagement, Elsy Merriweather is further disheartened when her book group flakes on their annual cabin weekend. Elsy decides to take a solo vacation, but a storm pushes her off course. She is shocked to realize that she's landed in Eloraton, the fictional town featured in her favorite romance novels. Everything is in place except for the grumpy, swoon-worthy bookstore owner, Anderson. The longer Elsy stays, the more she changes the story, and the more it changes her. As she tries to avoid falling for Anderson, who seems like he was written just for her, she must also find a way home. In this love letter to romance readers, Poston (The Seven Year Slip) sidesteps tropes to pen a novel story with great depth. Narrator Dorothy Dillingham Blue gives life to the characters, making each distinct. Her portrayal of Elsy brims with emotion and feeling, and Elsy's Georgia accent never veers into hokeyness. Author Poston reads the acknowledgments in a conversational tone that borders on overacting, but she reins it in for a touching testament about the lives readers give stories after they're written. VERDICT A must-read for romance lovers and anyone who loves the magic of stories.—Zoey Colglazier

Publishers Weekly
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved

Stranger Than Fiction meets Virgin River in this incandescently clever meta rom-com from Poston (The Seven Year Slip). English professor Eileen “Elsy” Merriweather feels frozen in place after her fiancé breaks up with her a week before their wedding. Thankfully, there’s the promise of a “week of wine and happily ever afters” when her Super Smutty Book Club vacations together in a cabin in the Catskills. When Elsy gets lost in a storm on the way there, however, she winds up in Eloraton, the fictional small-town setting of bestseller Rachel Flowers’s hit Quixotic Falls series, the romances that brought the Super Smutty Book Club together in the first place. Flowers died before she could finish the series and Eloraton is stuck at the point where she stopped writing. The owner of the local bookstore, Anderson Sinclair, is the only person aware there’s anything odd about the town. He warns Elsy not to make ripples or change things, but she feels compelled to help her favorite characters find the happy endings their author planned for them. Poston gracefully walks the line between women’s fiction and romance—with just a hint of magic—providing an inspirational story of personal growth and second-chance romance alongside a fascinating exploration of transformative fiction, how readers and writers cocreate and share stories, and the value and purpose of escaping into one’s favorite novels. Readers will want to escape into this one again and again. Agent: Holly Root, Root Literary. (June)

Library Journal
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

Elsy Merriweather has always felt most at home in books, especially romances, where the happily-ever-afters are guaranteed. Real life, on the other hand, has left her with a cancelled wedding and a best friend who's building a whole new life while Elsy simply feels stuck. When she's the only one who can make it to her book group's annual readathon vacation, she decides to go alone and lose herself in wine and her favorite series of romance novels, set in the charming small town of Eloraton. When Elsy's car breaks down in the middle of a fierce rainstorm, she's shocked to find herself surrounded by the familiar—fictional—buildings and residents of Eloraton itself. Elsy knows the town as well as her own heart (apart from one unfamiliar, grumpy bookstore owner), and as she settles into the routine of Eloraton, where every day is the same, she must decide if her own happily-ever-after is in Eloraton or back in the real world. VERDICT This slow-burn love story from Poston (The Seven Year Slip) is as much an ode to romance novels and friendship as it is about romantic relationships. Fans of small-town contemporary romance will sink easily into quaint Eloraton.—Meagan Day